Skip to main content
615 Gutter, gutter company in Nashville TN 615-431-3789

Comparing

Aluminum, Steel, Copper and Vinyl Gutters Compared

How the main gutter materials differ in strength, upkeep, look and typical uses.

2 minute read

Key takeaways

  • Aluminum is the most common choice and balances weight, rust resistance and color choice.
  • Steel is stiffer and stronger, and its finish must stay intact to resist rust.
  • Copper and zinc are premium metals that age naturally and last a long time.
  • Vinyl suits small roofs and outbuildings but has limits in cold and under heavy loads.

Aluminum

Aluminum is light, does not rust and can be roll-formed into long seamless runs on site. The finish is baked on at the factory in many colors. Thicker gauges resist dents better, and aluminum is the default choice for most homes.

It can dent from ladders and hail, and thin low-grade material feels flimsy, so gauge is worth asking about.

Steel and zinc

Galvanized and coated steel is stiff and strong. It pairs well with metal roofs and farm buildings. If the coating is scratched or the cut edges are not sealed, steel can rust. Zinc is a premium metal that weathers to a soft gray and lasts a long time.

Both need compatible fasteners and careful installation.

Copper

Copper starts bright and darkens to a rich brown, and over many years it may develop a blue-green patina. It is soldered rather than caulked, so it takes skill to install. It suits stone, brick and historic homes.

Copper should not touch bare aluminum or steel where water can run between them, because the metals can corrode.

Vinyl

Vinyl gutters snap together and do not rust. They suit sheds, garages and small roofs. In cold weather they can become brittle, and heavy leaf, ice or snow loads can crack or sag them. Colors are limited.

For most homes with trees or large roofs, metal is the more dependable choice.

Quick answers

Which gutter material lasts the longest?

Copper and zinc are known for long service, and well-installed aluminum and steel also last a long time. Installation and maintenance matter a great deal.

Do aluminum gutters rust?

No. Aluminum does not rust, though it can dent or wear at the finish.

Can I mix metals?

Be careful. Copper in contact with bare aluminum or steel can cause corrosion where water flows between them.

Related services

Questions about your project?

Call, text or send the form. Tell us about the house, what the gutters are doing and when you hope to start, and we will take it from there.

615-431-3789Text